|
JOHN TURZER
John Turzer is the President of JLT & Associates,
a full service real estate market research and training
company specializing in the manufactured housing industry.
The company conducts pre-acquisition and new community development
market research, due diligence, sales skills (shoppers reports)
evaluation services, a one-day sales training program and
client specific con-sulting projects.
JLT & Associates also prepares and markets manufactured home
community rent surveys for Albuquerque, Las Vegas, Greater Phoenix,
Tucson, Salt Lake City, Kansas City, Raleigh, Charlotte, Atlanta and
numerous counties in Florida, Texas, Michigan, Colorado, Indi-ana and
Ohio. He can be reach at (808) 283-3380, (808) 659-5517 (fax)
|
|
here are the "HOT" markets for purchasing existing communities and building new communities? What criteria do investors use to identify growing markets? This article will provide insight into how to identify growing markets and an executive summary of the markets for which JLT & Associates prepares annual manufactured home community rent surveys. These "tips" should guide investors and developers to identify quality investment and development opportunities in growing markets.
Identifying Growing Markets - When identifying growing markets, population and employment growth are two key indicators investors and developers look at to prepare a list of potential markets to analyze. This information identifies areas that most likely are experiencing strong economic growth. Job growth and population growth normally go hand in hand. People will migrate to areas where jobs are abundant. The top twenty-five Population Growth Markets from 1990 to 1996 are (minimum 60,000 new residents):
Identifying Growing Markets - When identifying growing markets, population and employment growth are two key indicators investors and developers look at to prepare a list of potential markets to analyze. This information identifies areas that most likely are experiencing strong economic growth. Job growth and population growth normally go hand in hand. People will migrate to areas where jobs are abundant. The top twenty-five Population Growth Markets from July 1997 to July 1998 are (minimum 13,000 new residents):

The top twenty-five Employment Growth Markets from September 1998 to September 1999 are (minimum 20,000 new jobs):

Investors and developers will also gather information on apartment rents, single family home prices and existing manufactured home community rents. This data is used to determine if manufactured homes are an affordable housing alternative. If monthly cost (home payment + homesite rent) to live in a new manufactured home is:
- equal to the monthly cost to live in a Class A or B two bedroom apartment,
- 20% to 30% below the monthly cost to live in a new starter single family home, and
- 20% to 30% below the monthly cost to live in the median priced pre-owned single family home,
Then manufactured homes are typically an affordable housing alternative.
If the findings are positive, investors and developers will determine:
- demand for existing and new homesites,
- if there are additional new communities in the planning process or under construction,
- land availability and costs,
- access to public water and sewer, attitudes of local planning and zoning officials towards manufactured home community expansion and development,
- local crime rates, and
- quality of public school education.
Craig White, Vice President of Acquisitions for CWS Capital Partners comments on some of the criteria his organization evaluates.
"With regard to the criteria mentioned above, we use all of that data.
We feel that long term job growth, the differential between single family
and manufactured home living and difficulty of entry into a market are the
strongest factors that are considered in the development of a new community.
We like high barrier to entry markets and markets where the cost of single
family housing is the highest. Currently, we have greenfield development projects
underway in Austin and Denver. With regards to acquiring existing communities, we look at
the desirability of the community and its location plus the criteria mentioned above."
Rees Davis, Executive Vice President for Chateau Communities also indicated that Chateau Communities
"uses all of the criteria noted above when evaluating the purchase of existing communities
and land for development. We focus on the long-term growth of the market and the asset's
position relative to comparable competing communities." He further adds, "Better
than average job and population growth concurrent with a lack of affordable housing
will always be the underlying drivers of a good market. Chateau looks for markets where
rents can be increased from 3% to 7% per annum while maintaining high occupancy rates.
When evaluating development opportunities, barriers to entry into the market and the existing
pipeline of new communities/sites are critical factors we look at. We continue to avoid markets
that have low barriers of entry, a lack of economic diversification and a smaller population base."
Snap-shot Look at Various Markets - Annually, we prepare manufactured home community rent surveys for forty-nine (49) markets nationwide. Findings and Observations about each market are presented in Exhibit A.
Comments and Observations
New community development is strong in San Antonio and Austin. In the San Antonio market, eleven (11) communities (over 4,700 new homesites) are being developed and/or proposed. In the Austin market, four (4) communities totaling 1,367 homesites have opened since October 1998. In addition, nine (9) communities (over 4,200 new homesites) are being developed and/or proposed. Overbuilding, however, is occurring in both markets. Consequently, absorption rates may not match proformas. Very aggressive marketing promotions such as free and/or reduced rent for at least two years, referral fee payments to local manufactured home retailers and cash rebates to new residents ranging from $1,500 to $4,000 will be needed to fill homesites.
Zoning bias (NIMBY - not in my neighborhood) is the chief hurdle facing developers in most markets. Despite the need for quality affordable housing in many growing markets such as Raleigh, North Carolina, and laws prohibiting more stringent development requirements for manufactured home communities, local zoning boards continue to deny applications for new community development. Opposing residents normally cite an increased burden on local school districts, increased vehicular traffic, the perceived devaluation of their homes and neighbors caused by allowing "trailers" in their neighborhoods, increased crime and discriminatory comments about people who live in "mobile homes or trailers". Developers either "fold their tent" or are forced to sue the local municipality. Lawsuits are expensive and time consuming. Developers must engage a full array of "expert" witnesses and consultants to mitigate the comments cited above. Developers have won judgments to permit new community development in Sandstone Township (near Jackson) Michigan and Pennfield Township Michigan (near Battle Creek). Other lawsuits are planned or in process. The litigation process, although successful in many cases, adds significant cost and time delays and creates an adversarial relationship between the developer, local municipality officials and neighborhood residents.
When markets become "hot", land prices increase and create a major financial hurdle for developing new communities.
In many cases, developers cannot "make the numbers work out".
Consequently, manufactured housing is not an affordable housing alternative
because the spread between living in a single family home and a manufactured home is minimal.
High land costs coupled with traditional development costs yields a "market rent" that when added
to the monthly cost of a new manufactured home does not make manufactured housing an affordable housing option.
This situation has been a major factor limiting development in Las Vegas.
Well over 90% of the existing communities in the Houston market cannot accommodate modern size single and multi-section homes. Further, for many years, single family homes were among the most affordable nationwide. Therefore, to remain an affordable housing option, monthly rents were "capped" at $200. A strong increase in single family home prices coupled with the lack communities that can accommodate modern sized homes has spurred the development of new communities in the Houston market. Rents will range from $225 to $250 per month.
A demand for new communities exists when local manufactured home retailers reserve vacant homesites and pay the monthly rent and local retailers build new communities. Retailers are reserving vacant homesites that can accommodate modern sized single and multi-section homes in Akron, Cincinnati, Columbus and Dayton. Retailers are building new communities in the Indianapolis area.
Florida communities face stiff competition from affordable single family homes and modern, lifestyle oriented condominium and single family home communities. Many of the lifestyle oriented "55+" manufactured home communities are well over twenty-five years old. Amenities are dated in appearance, style and dcor. Most of the existing homes are older and do not offer the decor and conveniences found in new manufactured homes, condos and single family homes. Occupancy rates have leveled off . New community development is almost non-existent.
|